1803–1804 · Port Phillip Bay · Sullivan Bay
Collins Settlement: The Ships and the Voyage from Portsmouth
The first European settlement in Victoria was not founded by a fleet of purpose-built transports. It was carried in a 52-gun warship borrowed from the East India Company and a chartered copper-bottomed brig, which sailed from Portsmouth on 27 April 1803 and arrived six months later at a harbour nobody aboard had seen. Within four months the settlement at Sullivan Bay would be abandoned.
The two ships
The Ocean was a copper-bottomed brig of about 480 tonnes, possibly built at Newcastle in the late 1700s. The British Government chartered her from Messrs Hurry & Co as a supply ship. She carried about 100 people: her captain John Mertho, nine officers, 26 seamen, eight civil officers — among them the surveyor George Harris and the mineralogist Adolarius Humphrey — and a group of free settlers chosen for their trades. Five were carpenters, two were seamen, two were millers, and the rest included a whitesmith, a stonemason, a gardener, a painter, a schoolteacher, a pocketbook maker and two servants.
HMS Calcutta was the fighting ship: 1,200 tonnes, 52 guns, built of teak in 1788 for the East India Company and originally named Warley. Her main deck ran 60 metres, her beam was 10 metres, and she stood 61 metres to the top of her mast. She could make 12 knots. For this voyage she was modified to carry convicts and packed with roughly 640 people — convicts, some with wives and families, 23 officers, 150 seamen, and 109 marines, half of them destined to be the colony's garrison.
Fitting out for convicts
Two prison rooms were built on the Calcutta, and most convicts were housed in them. The rest were put to work: sixteen as servants to the civil and military officers, nineteen as sailors, and twenty on deck, mostly as cooks.
Married convicts were allowed to bring their wives as servants, an incentive to good behaviour. Seventeen wives, including two unmarried women, made the voyage with their husbands, along with six sons and five daughters.
Comfort was negotiable. John Fawkner, a metal refiner transported for fourteen years for receiving stolen goods, paid the boatswain twenty guineas for his cabin and shared it with his wife Hannah, their son John Pascoe Fawkner — later a founder of Melbourne — and their daughter Elizabeth. James Grove rented the carpenter's cabin for twenty pounds.
Discipline ran in parallel. John Jones took a dozen lashes for theft before the ship left Portsmouth, then attempted to desert at Rio de Janeiro and took another dozen. During a sea trial before departure the Calcutta was struck by a violent storm, and the midshipman Thomas Penn fell from the rigging while furling sails, fractured his skull and died.
Tenerife, a slaver, and Rio
The ships reached Santa Cruz on Tenerife on 17 May and sailed again on 21 May, arriving at Rio de Janeiro on 29 June. Ten days out of Portsmouth, on 11 May, Captain Woodriff of the Calcutta sighted a strange sail: the Rio Nova, carrying more than 300 enslaved people from West Africa to Demerara. There had been a mutiny aboard, and Woodriff sent five marines to detain three of the ringleaders in irons.
At Rio the ships took on fresh provisions — 36 turkeys, thirteen dozen capons and fowls, 68 very large ducks, four geese, 13 pigs and a large quantity of fruit and vegetables — while rigging was repaired and water replenished. Woodriff also sent five marines under Lieutenant Sladden to keep order aboard the Ocean, where relations between the free settlers and Captain Mertho had soured. The settlers thought him a tyrant; he thought them intractable.
Desertion was a constant problem. Seven sailors left the Calcutta at Rio; three were caught by Portuguese soldiers who were paid six pounds a head for their trouble. Two more deserted at Cape Town, and one was recaptured.
The last leg
The Ocean was the slower ship, and was ordered to sail direct for Port Phillip if the two lost contact. They did. She ran through the Southern Atlantic and into the Indian Ocean and endured 77 days of frightening weather before sighting land on 5 October.
“For many days we could not sit at table but were obliged to hold fast by boxes and on the floor, and all our crockery were almost broken to pieces, besides many seas into the cabin and living in the state of darkness from the cabin windows being stopped up by the deadlights… I was never so melancholy in my life before.” — George Harris, surveyor, aboard the Ocean
Work on deck in those conditions was lethal. On 9 August the sailor John Bowers fell overboard and was lost.
When Captain Mertho sighted land he could not find the entrance to the bay through the gale. The mineralogist Adolarius Humphrey recorded that the captain began to be uneasy, fearing that if this were not Port Phillip he could not beat off the coast, with breakers visible right across the opening. The gale eased, and with soundings taken from an open boat the Ocean crept in. She anchored on 7 October 1803.
The Calcutta had reached Cape Town on 13 August, taken on 5,000 pounds of fresh beef and mutton, 300 pounds of soft bread, three cows, two bulls and twelve sheep, and sailed on 25 August. On 6 October she sighted King Island and was nearly wrecked by a hurricane that blew every sail from the yards. She entered Port Phillip two days after the Ocean to find her already at anchor.
For all the hardship, health aboard was generally good. Eight convicts died on the voyage, mostly of scurvy, despite the fresh produce bought at Tenerife and Rio. Lieutenant Tuckey thought monotony the defining feature of the passage: the effect of seeing the smallest spot of land, or even a bare uninhabited rock, was, he wrote, easier felt than described.
What became of the ships
The settlement at Sullivan Bay lasted barely four months before Collins moved his people to Van Diemen's Land, and the Ocean helped carry them. She was then released from government service, sailed to Sydney, took on provisions and headed for China, calling at the Micronesian island of Banada and the Marshall Islands in November 1804. Her later fate, and that of Captain Mertho, is not known.
The Calcutta reached Portsmouth from Sydney on 24 July 1804 and was assigned to convoy duty against the French. On 25 August she sighted a convoy of enemy sail, drove off the Armede, and then fought the far stronger Magnanime for almost an hour before surrendering. Woodriff wrote that enemy gunfire had completely unrigged his ship and that to continue would only sacrifice the lives of his people. She later served under the French flag and was destroyed in action against the Royal Navy in April 1809.
Good to know
- Departed: Portsmouth, 27 April 1803
- Arrived: Port Phillip Bay, 7 October 1803 (Ocean), two days later (Calcutta)
- Aboard: about 100 on the Ocean, about 640 on the Calcutta
- Site: Sullivan Bay, Sorrento — the graves of the settlement are still there
- Outcome: abandoned within four months; the settlers were moved to Van Diemen's Land
Related stories: Sorrento visitor guide · Point Nepean Quarantine Station · More Peninsula history
More from the archive: Balcombe Army Camp · Frankston's waterfront
Sources include No Place for a Colony by Richard Cotter, Mornington: In the Wake of Flinders by Leslie Moorhead, the logs of the Lady Nelson, James Hingston Tuckey's 1805 account of the voyage, and the Australian Dictionary of Biography.